Most of us scroll past the liability waiver and tap “agree.” A Colorado Supreme Court decision last month is a good reason to slow down, at least once.
In a 4-3 ruling in late September, the court dismissed an injury lawsuit against Vail Resorts after the plaintiff, a snowboarder who had been hurt at Breckenridge, bought a new Epic Pass and accepted the pass’s terms while his case was still active. The case is Litterer v. Vail Summit Resorts, Inc., and the reaction has been strong in both directions. We have read several accounts, including the Colorado Sun, the Colorado Springs Gazette, the Vail Daily, a Teton Gravity Research explainer, and a law firm’s summary. To be clear up front, we are not lawyers, and nothing here is legal advice. Here is what the reporting says, and why it is worth understanding.
What happened in the case?
According to those accounts, John Litterer was snowboarding at Breckenridge in December 2020 when he was struck by a snowmobile operated by a resort employee. He sued Vail Resorts and the operator. While that lawsuit was pending, he bought another Epic Pass for the 2022-23 season and electronically accepted its terms, which included language covering anything that had happened up to that point.
Vail argued that by accepting those terms, he had released his existing claim. A divided Colorado Supreme Court agreed and dismissed the case. PlanetSKI reported that he is expected to owe Vail around $60,000 in costs.
Why was the ruling so close?
The majority drew a distinction between two kinds of agreements. A pre-injury waiver, signed before anything has happened, is something courts have long scrutinized, and Colorado has its own case law on how far those can go. A post-injury release, which expressly covers events that have already occurred, is treated differently. The majority saw the Epic Pass language, accepted after the accident, as the second kind.
Three justices disagreed. Their concern, as summarized in the coverage, is that the reasoning could let resorts use similar language in routine agreements to extinguish claims that already exist. Whether that worry proves justified will depend on how lower courts apply the decision.
Where did the case come from?
The facts have been reported fairly consistently. The collision was in December 2020, the lawsuit followed, and the case worked its way up through Colorado’s courts before reaching the state Supreme Court this year. The question that reached the justices was narrow. It was not whether the resort was at fault for the collision. It was whether the later Epic Pass agreement closed the door on the lawsuit before that question could be answered.
That distinction is why you may see the ruling described as a procedural outcome rather than a verdict on the accident itself. The merits of what happened on the mountain were not decided.
What did the court not decide?
This is the part that tends to get lost in headlines. Based on the accounts we read, the ruling is narrow. It does not say that every Epic Pass lawsuit is dead, and it does not overturn Colorado’s earlier case law on waivers signed before an injury. It addresses what happens when someone with an open claim later agrees to a document that explicitly releases past events.
It also does not tell you anything about how a different resort, a different pass, or a different state would be treated. Waiver law varies a lot across jurisdictions.
Why do these agreements look the way they do?
Resorts sell millions of day tickets and passes, and every one of them carries terms the buyer accepts in seconds. Companies write those terms to cover as much as the law allows, and courts then decide where the line is. Colorado has been one of the states where that line has been tested repeatedly, which is part of why this case drew so much attention from lawyers outside the ski industry.
For an ordinary skier, the practical point is simple. The terms on a pass page are not boilerplate in the sense of being meaningless. They are the document a court will read if something goes wrong.
What should skiers actually take from this?
A few practical points, none of them dramatic.
Read what you accept after an incident. If you have an injury claim or an open dispute with a resort or any outfitter, be cautious about clicking through new terms, including pass purchases and renewals. Talk to an attorney first. That is the plain-spoken takeaway from nearly every legal summary of the decision.
Know that passes and tickets are contracts. The checkbox on a pass purchase page is not a formality. If you ski, ride, or climb, it is worth reading the section on release of claims at least once.
Remember that guides and instructors have their own paperwork. When you hire a private instructor or a guide, you will usually sign a separate release for that service. It is reasonable to ask what it covers, whether the professional carries insurance, and who the operating entity is. Our guide to questions to ask any guide before you go includes the safety and insurance questions we think every customer should ask, and the same applies to heli-skiing, climbing, and whitewater.
Why does this matter beyond one case?
The ruling lands in a year when Vail Resorts is already under heavy scrutiny, and it will be read by lawyers at every large operator in the country. Even if it never affects you, it is a reminder of how much of a ski day is governed by documents most of us have never opened.
None of that should scare anyone off the mountain. Skiing remains a sport with managed risk, and most days end with nothing more than sore legs. But there is a difference between accepting risk and understanding what you have agreed to. Spending ten minutes reading the terms before a season starts is a cheap way to know the difference.
MEETR is a marketplace for finding outdoor guides and instructors. Search by discipline and location, see the professional before you book, and plan the day with someone who knows the country you are standing in. Find your pro at meetr.pro.
